I
Indian
Guest
Allah committed shirk (Associated others with himself)
Muhammad committed Shirk (Associated himself with Allah )
In-effect Quran establishes the fact that Both Allah and Muhammad contradicted its fundamental message and proved themselves unpardonable as per Sura 4:48
Here are the reference from Quran and Hadith
Sura 4: 48 Indeed, Allah does not forgive association with Him, but He forgives what is less than that for whom He wills. And he who associates others with Allah has certainly fabricated a tremendous sin.
What has hadith to say about SHIRK- Swearing by someone other than Allah
1. Shahi Bukhari 6108 Allah forbids you to swear by your Fathers. If anyone has to take an oath, he should swear by allah or otherwise keep quite;
2. Shahi Muslim 4040 He who has to take an oath he must not take an oath but by Allah
3. Abu Daud 3242 Muhammad said- Do not swear by your fathers or by your mothers, or by rivals to allah; and swear by allah only , and swear by Allah only when you are speaking the truth
4. Sunan An Nasai 3795 Muhammad said whoever swears let him not swear by anything other than Allah
5. Sunan Ibn Majah 2095 Muhammad said do not take oaths by idols or your forefathers;
Jami At Tirmidhi (Student of Bukhari) 1534 When Umar was swearing by his father, Muhammad came to him and said verily Allah prohibits you from swearing by your fathers. So let the one who swears do so by Allah
Jami At Tirmidhi 1535- Ibn Umar said Nothing is sworn by other than Allah, for I heard the messenger of Allah say – whoever swears by other than Allah has Committed disbelief or shirk
Conclusion : So SWEARING BY ANY OTHER is making them Allah’s partner;
Case 1: Allah committed Shirk by swearing on others
Partner 1: Allah swears by Quran Sura 36:2, 38:1, 43:2, 50:1
So Allah just declared that Quran is his partner!!
So if Quran is eternal it implies quran existed since Allah existed, but quran as per your own book and teachings is a separate entity than Allah; So you just conceded that Islamic teaching in error (based on your mathematics) because it wants you to believe 1+1 = 1
Partner 2: Allah swears by Muhammad’s life 15:72 – Verily by thy life (o prophet), in their wild intoxication, they wander…
So Allah considers Muhammad a partner
Partner 3: Allah swears by angels as partners too; Sura 77: 5 , 79:1 So Angels are allah’s devine partners
Allah seems quite lonely
Partner 4: Swears by stars Sura 81:15 , 85:1, 56:75
Partner 5: Swear by Sun and brilliance Sura 91:1
Partner 6: Swear by earth and its expanse Sura 91:6
Partner 7: Swear by the moon Sura 74:32
Partner 8: Swear by Daybreak sURA 89:1
Partner 9: Swear by Sunset Sura 84:16
Partner 10 : Swear by the night : Sura 92:1
Partner 11: Swear By the rain giving wind Sura 86:11
Partner 12: Swears By Wind Sura 51:1
Partner 13: Swear by Mecca, Sura 90:1
Partner 14: Swear by Even and ODD Sura 89:3
Partner 15 : Swear by Fig, olive, mt sinai, this city S 95:1-3
Looks like Allah just can’t resist the temptation to make everything and anything his partner!!!!
Now your teachers have been telling you (based on quran and hadith) if you swear by anything created, that being insignificant compared to Allah, so it is the most terrible sin;
Ultimate Partner 16: Sura 69:38 39 I swear by that which you see and do not see, so everything conceivable is a partner;
Conclusion: So Islam is not monotheist, but potentially pantheistic / Polytheistic
So Allah mentioned all these swearing in his eternal word Quran there by eternally committing shirk; So practically Allah himself is the the worst sinners / blasphemer of all time;
Shirk is the unforgiveable sin as per quran, and Allah himself committed this;
Seriousness of Allah’s error :
Sura 2: 22 Do not set up rivals to Allah while you know,
So more knowledge , more responsible, Now, Allah cannot appeal to ignorance,
Here is clarity of logic for you …
Premise 1: Shirk is the worst possible sin
Premise 2: You commit shirk when you swear by anything other than allah
Premise 3: Since allah swears by everything seen and unseen
Conclusion 1: Allah has committed more shirk than anyone else,
Premise 4: Because Allah knows more than anyone else, so he is more responsible than anyone else, while repeatedly committing the same sin;
Conclusion 2: So according to Quran and Muhammads own statements, – Allah is the worst blasphemer ever to exist; the real mushrik!!!
Here is GREAT GOOD NEWS FOR YOU
If you come to Jesus – YOU WILL NOT HAVE TO FEAR THIS LACK OF CREDIBILITY/ SELF ESTEEM OR LACK OF OMNIPOTENCE/ OMNISCIENCE/ on the part of JESUS
The God of bible only swears by his own name; and so we can 100% trust his claims;
But Allah deceived Muhammad into a lie (When he claimed he is singularly one); Moreover, Muhammad seems to lack judgment when he repeatedly gave revelation that contradicted his own other piece of revelation. But Muslims are following him like a sheep to the slaughter, not realizing that the one you are currently calling upon does not even have the confidence to swear by his own name!!!!
The foolishness of the counterfeit;
Islam uncovers its own nakedness by telling you part truth – viz.. Oneness of God, but unable to fathom the complexity of eternal infinite being ; and in the process, committing foolishness – infact foolishness committed by all 3 principal characters- Allah! Quran!! Muhammad!!!
Case 2: Quran claims to be distinct from allah yet eternal
Quran claims that it is Eternally existing book, separate from Allah ( Not in the mind of Allah)
Sura 43:4: Mother of all books
13:39 .. And with him is the mother of books (Quran)
85:21, 22: Honored Quran- Preserved in a slate
56:78 IN a register well protected
17:105 Allah has sent Quran
Did you even realize the error of judgment by Allah- He said Quran is a distinct book written – on a slate ( so pen was used) … In effect he claimed a book, some clay (Slate) , a pen all are eternal – because all these together produce a actual book preserved eternally in heaven;
So Quran exists as a distinct book but is also eternal ; But Allah is also eternal; So there are 2 eternal entities, one a singular God Allah, and another an eternal book Quran; there are 2 eternal entities but how is this 1+1=1..?
More trouble : Muhammad committed SHIRK!!
CASE 3: Quran deifies Muhammad thereby committing shirk by Qurans own standards
Problem 1: Quran claims Allah has some unique characters : “ Allah is Most kind most merciful”
2:143; 16:47-; 22:65 ; 24:20; 9:117
However, as per 9:-128 “There has certainly come to you a Messenger from among yourselves. Grievous to him is what you suffer; [he is] concerned over you and to the believers is kind and merciful.”
Muhammad holds the attributes that are unique to Allah!!!
Remember it is one of the last Medinan Sura; Looks like the prophet who initially started claiming to be a mere man found this an interesting proposition to claim for himself some unique characteristics of Allah.
So Muhammad started by telling you muslims to claim Allah is most kind and merciful and towards the end he took up that so called unique attribute on himself and said count me at that level;
Significance as narrated in Hadith-
Sahih Muslim 30/5811 Jubair Bin, narrated : Messenger said ”I have many names, I am mohammed, Ahmaad, Al Mahi ( Obliterator of unbelief) hasher (gatherer ), Aquib (No one like me), I am named compassionate and Merciful”.
Allah honored Muhammad with his own attribute
How does muslim sources understand this: Al hussain ibn al fadil – Allah honored Muhammad with 2 of his own attributes – the compassionate one and the merciful one;
Jafar ibn Muhammad- Allah knew – No creature can achieve absolute purity to serve allah, so he ( allah) put a mediator, from human species, by clothing him in his own attributes so now if someone obeys him obeys me;
So believes/ obeys MUHAMMAD you are obeying ALLAH
Rishad khalifa had problems with sahada; he asked how can we take Muhammad’s name with Allah; And he also argued this verse cannot be in quran;
Problem 2: SINGULAR PRONOUN TO GROUP UP ALLAH AND MUHAMMAD
If Muhammad is mere man, why does Quran take the name of both Allah and Muhammad and then used Singular pronoun to address; Here are some examples
Sura 8:20 O you who have believed, obey Allah and His Messenger and do not turn from HIM while you hear [his order].
Sura 8:24 O you who have believed, respond to Allah and to the Messenger when HE CALLS YOU to that which gives you life. And know that Allah intervenes between a man and his heart and that to Him you will be gathered.
Here is how Al Bukhari Hadith explains this verse
Bukhari 6/60/1 Abu Said bin Almuala said – While I was praying (SALAH) [ ACT OF WORSHIP IN iSLAM} in the masjid allah’s apostle called me but I did not respond; Muhammad, said, didn’t Allah say – “Give response to allah by obeying the messenger. So when you hear Muhammad even if you are practicing the most virtuous Islamic practice of praying to Allah, you must leave that and harken to the call of Prophet; because Muhammad calling is same as Allah
Conclusion: This is a clear deification of Muhammad to stand equal to Allah
So Muhammad is human manifestation of Allah clothed in his attributes
So Muhammad is forcing the idea that he is Human manifestation of ALLAH- SHIRK!!!!!
He is claiming to hold the attributes that can only be Allah’s Attributes
Final conclusion:
You say that 1+1 cannot be 1 which we Christians completely agree with you; But the point we Christians have been telling you is that this equation is your problem to handle not Christian; Because Christians do not believe about trinity with such foolish equation;
It is the claim between of relationship between Allah Quran and Muhammad that end up in this trouble;
ALLAH ADDS PARTNERS TO HIM YET CLAIMS TO BE ONE
Quran claims to be eternal yet distinct from Allah thereby creating dualism ;
Muhammad claims qualities of Allah which he himself proclaims that only Allah can possess; There by equating himself to Allah
So you have to solve this trouble in Islam how you call 1+1+1 to be equal to 1
1. Allah committed Shirk
2. Quran committed shirk
3. Muhammad committed Shirk
Why follow these blasphemers? leave them; you will not lose anything good; Infact you will gain life by rejecting them and in receiving Jesus Christ as the LORD AND SAVIOUR of your life; Lord Jesus is not offended by all the foolishness you spoke about him till now; He is not like Allah or Muhammad to come after you in revenge or curses!!!;
Rather Jesus forgives, and cleans you up and gives you a new heart and a new life you will never regret;
Bow down to Jesus!!! And receive life!!!!
Continue reading...
Muhammad committed Shirk (Associated himself with Allah )
In-effect Quran establishes the fact that Both Allah and Muhammad contradicted its fundamental message and proved themselves unpardonable as per Sura 4:48
Here are the reference from Quran and Hadith
Sura 4: 48 Indeed, Allah does not forgive association with Him, but He forgives what is less than that for whom He wills. And he who associates others with Allah has certainly fabricated a tremendous sin.
What has hadith to say about SHIRK- Swearing by someone other than Allah
1. Shahi Bukhari 6108 Allah forbids you to swear by your Fathers. If anyone has to take an oath, he should swear by allah or otherwise keep quite;
2. Shahi Muslim 4040 He who has to take an oath he must not take an oath but by Allah
3. Abu Daud 3242 Muhammad said- Do not swear by your fathers or by your mothers, or by rivals to allah; and swear by allah only , and swear by Allah only when you are speaking the truth
4. Sunan An Nasai 3795 Muhammad said whoever swears let him not swear by anything other than Allah
5. Sunan Ibn Majah 2095 Muhammad said do not take oaths by idols or your forefathers;
Jami At Tirmidhi (Student of Bukhari) 1534 When Umar was swearing by his father, Muhammad came to him and said verily Allah prohibits you from swearing by your fathers. So let the one who swears do so by Allah
Jami At Tirmidhi 1535- Ibn Umar said Nothing is sworn by other than Allah, for I heard the messenger of Allah say – whoever swears by other than Allah has Committed disbelief or shirk
Conclusion : So SWEARING BY ANY OTHER is making them Allah’s partner;
Case 1: Allah committed Shirk by swearing on others
Partner 1: Allah swears by Quran Sura 36:2, 38:1, 43:2, 50:1
So Allah just declared that Quran is his partner!!
So if Quran is eternal it implies quran existed since Allah existed, but quran as per your own book and teachings is a separate entity than Allah; So you just conceded that Islamic teaching in error (based on your mathematics) because it wants you to believe 1+1 = 1
Partner 2: Allah swears by Muhammad’s life 15:72 – Verily by thy life (o prophet), in their wild intoxication, they wander…
So Allah considers Muhammad a partner
Partner 3: Allah swears by angels as partners too; Sura 77: 5 , 79:1 So Angels are allah’s devine partners
Allah seems quite lonely
Partner 4: Swears by stars Sura 81:15 , 85:1, 56:75
Partner 5: Swear by Sun and brilliance Sura 91:1
Partner 6: Swear by earth and its expanse Sura 91:6
Partner 7: Swear by the moon Sura 74:32
Partner 8: Swear by Daybreak sURA 89:1
Partner 9: Swear by Sunset Sura 84:16
Partner 10 : Swear by the night : Sura 92:1
Partner 11: Swear By the rain giving wind Sura 86:11
Partner 12: Swears By Wind Sura 51:1
Partner 13: Swear by Mecca, Sura 90:1
Partner 14: Swear by Even and ODD Sura 89:3
Partner 15 : Swear by Fig, olive, mt sinai, this city S 95:1-3
Looks like Allah just can’t resist the temptation to make everything and anything his partner!!!!
Now your teachers have been telling you (based on quran and hadith) if you swear by anything created, that being insignificant compared to Allah, so it is the most terrible sin;
Ultimate Partner 16: Sura 69:38 39 I swear by that which you see and do not see, so everything conceivable is a partner;
Conclusion: So Islam is not monotheist, but potentially pantheistic / Polytheistic
So Allah mentioned all these swearing in his eternal word Quran there by eternally committing shirk; So practically Allah himself is the the worst sinners / blasphemer of all time;
Shirk is the unforgiveable sin as per quran, and Allah himself committed this;
Seriousness of Allah’s error :
Sura 2: 22 Do not set up rivals to Allah while you know,
So more knowledge , more responsible, Now, Allah cannot appeal to ignorance,
Here is clarity of logic for you …
Premise 1: Shirk is the worst possible sin
Premise 2: You commit shirk when you swear by anything other than allah
Premise 3: Since allah swears by everything seen and unseen
Conclusion 1: Allah has committed more shirk than anyone else,
Premise 4: Because Allah knows more than anyone else, so he is more responsible than anyone else, while repeatedly committing the same sin;
Conclusion 2: So according to Quran and Muhammads own statements, – Allah is the worst blasphemer ever to exist; the real mushrik!!!
Here is GREAT GOOD NEWS FOR YOU
If you come to Jesus – YOU WILL NOT HAVE TO FEAR THIS LACK OF CREDIBILITY/ SELF ESTEEM OR LACK OF OMNIPOTENCE/ OMNISCIENCE/ on the part of JESUS
The God of bible only swears by his own name; and so we can 100% trust his claims;
But Allah deceived Muhammad into a lie (When he claimed he is singularly one); Moreover, Muhammad seems to lack judgment when he repeatedly gave revelation that contradicted his own other piece of revelation. But Muslims are following him like a sheep to the slaughter, not realizing that the one you are currently calling upon does not even have the confidence to swear by his own name!!!!
The foolishness of the counterfeit;
Islam uncovers its own nakedness by telling you part truth – viz.. Oneness of God, but unable to fathom the complexity of eternal infinite being ; and in the process, committing foolishness – infact foolishness committed by all 3 principal characters- Allah! Quran!! Muhammad!!!
Case 2: Quran claims to be distinct from allah yet eternal
Quran claims that it is Eternally existing book, separate from Allah ( Not in the mind of Allah)
Sura 43:4: Mother of all books
13:39 .. And with him is the mother of books (Quran)
85:21, 22: Honored Quran- Preserved in a slate
56:78 IN a register well protected
17:105 Allah has sent Quran
Did you even realize the error of judgment by Allah- He said Quran is a distinct book written – on a slate ( so pen was used) … In effect he claimed a book, some clay (Slate) , a pen all are eternal – because all these together produce a actual book preserved eternally in heaven;
So Quran exists as a distinct book but is also eternal ; But Allah is also eternal; So there are 2 eternal entities, one a singular God Allah, and another an eternal book Quran; there are 2 eternal entities but how is this 1+1=1..?
More trouble : Muhammad committed SHIRK!!
CASE 3: Quran deifies Muhammad thereby committing shirk by Qurans own standards
Problem 1: Quran claims Allah has some unique characters : “ Allah is Most kind most merciful”
2:143; 16:47-; 22:65 ; 24:20; 9:117
However, as per 9:-128 “There has certainly come to you a Messenger from among yourselves. Grievous to him is what you suffer; [he is] concerned over you and to the believers is kind and merciful.”
Muhammad holds the attributes that are unique to Allah!!!
Remember it is one of the last Medinan Sura; Looks like the prophet who initially started claiming to be a mere man found this an interesting proposition to claim for himself some unique characteristics of Allah.
So Muhammad started by telling you muslims to claim Allah is most kind and merciful and towards the end he took up that so called unique attribute on himself and said count me at that level;
Significance as narrated in Hadith-
Sahih Muslim 30/5811 Jubair Bin, narrated : Messenger said ”I have many names, I am mohammed, Ahmaad, Al Mahi ( Obliterator of unbelief) hasher (gatherer ), Aquib (No one like me), I am named compassionate and Merciful”.
Allah honored Muhammad with his own attribute
How does muslim sources understand this: Al hussain ibn al fadil – Allah honored Muhammad with 2 of his own attributes – the compassionate one and the merciful one;
Jafar ibn Muhammad- Allah knew – No creature can achieve absolute purity to serve allah, so he ( allah) put a mediator, from human species, by clothing him in his own attributes so now if someone obeys him obeys me;
So believes/ obeys MUHAMMAD you are obeying ALLAH
Rishad khalifa had problems with sahada; he asked how can we take Muhammad’s name with Allah; And he also argued this verse cannot be in quran;
Problem 2: SINGULAR PRONOUN TO GROUP UP ALLAH AND MUHAMMAD
If Muhammad is mere man, why does Quran take the name of both Allah and Muhammad and then used Singular pronoun to address; Here are some examples
Sura 8:20 O you who have believed, obey Allah and His Messenger and do not turn from HIM while you hear [his order].
Sura 8:24 O you who have believed, respond to Allah and to the Messenger when HE CALLS YOU to that which gives you life. And know that Allah intervenes between a man and his heart and that to Him you will be gathered.
Here is how Al Bukhari Hadith explains this verse
Bukhari 6/60/1 Abu Said bin Almuala said – While I was praying (SALAH) [ ACT OF WORSHIP IN iSLAM} in the masjid allah’s apostle called me but I did not respond; Muhammad, said, didn’t Allah say – “Give response to allah by obeying the messenger. So when you hear Muhammad even if you are practicing the most virtuous Islamic practice of praying to Allah, you must leave that and harken to the call of Prophet; because Muhammad calling is same as Allah
Conclusion: This is a clear deification of Muhammad to stand equal to Allah
So Muhammad is human manifestation of Allah clothed in his attributes
So Muhammad is forcing the idea that he is Human manifestation of ALLAH- SHIRK!!!!!
He is claiming to hold the attributes that can only be Allah’s Attributes
Final conclusion:
You say that 1+1 cannot be 1 which we Christians completely agree with you; But the point we Christians have been telling you is that this equation is your problem to handle not Christian; Because Christians do not believe about trinity with such foolish equation;
It is the claim between of relationship between Allah Quran and Muhammad that end up in this trouble;
ALLAH ADDS PARTNERS TO HIM YET CLAIMS TO BE ONE
Quran claims to be eternal yet distinct from Allah thereby creating dualism ;
Muhammad claims qualities of Allah which he himself proclaims that only Allah can possess; There by equating himself to Allah
So you have to solve this trouble in Islam how you call 1+1+1 to be equal to 1
1. Allah committed Shirk
2. Quran committed shirk
3. Muhammad committed Shirk
Why follow these blasphemers? leave them; you will not lose anything good; Infact you will gain life by rejecting them and in receiving Jesus Christ as the LORD AND SAVIOUR of your life; Lord Jesus is not offended by all the foolishness you spoke about him till now; He is not like Allah or Muhammad to come after you in revenge or curses!!!;
Rather Jesus forgives, and cleans you up and gives you a new heart and a new life you will never regret;
Bow down to Jesus!!! And receive life!!!!
Continue reading...