Do Muslims Have the True History of Islam? NOOOO!!

I

Indian

Guest
Question 1: Does Islam use credible sources as their religious books?

Question 2: Can Muslims be confident that they have the true history of events during 7th century- (Muhammad’s life time)?

Question 3: Is Quran the unchanged Word of True God?

Question4: Can Muslims prove they today read the actual revelation Muhamamd received from Allah?

Let us look at the dating of each of their important books:

Note : Hadiths are the set of books Muslims consider the sayings of Muhamamd / and list of practices of Muhammad and is used as their primary source to interpret Quran

PART 1: REGARDING HADITHS

LIST OF HADITH COLLECTIONS BY DATE :

  1. Sahih Bukhari 870 AD 250 years after death of Muhamamd
  2. Sahih Muslim 875 AD 250+ years after death of Muhamamd
  3. Sunan Al Nasai 915 AD 300 years after death of Muhamamd
  4. Sunan Abu Dawood 888 AD 260+ years after death of Muhamamd
  5. Jami At Tirmidhi 892 AD 280+ years after death of Muhamamd
  6. Sunan Ibn Majah 887 AD 260+ years after death of Muhamamd
  7. Muwatta Malik ( Imam Malik ibn Abbas) 711-795 AD – 150+ years after death of Muhamamd His grandfather – student of Umar and involved in helping Uthaman create his recension!! (From Medina)
  1. Musnad Ahmad (Ahmad Ibn Hambal) 855 AD 230+ years after death of Muhamamd
  2. Riyad us Saliheen 1233-1277 AD Damascus 610+ years after death of Muhamamd
  3. Shamail Muhammadiyah Compiled Tirmidhi 280+ years after death ofMuhamamd
  4. Al Adab Al Mufrad ( Imam Bukhari) 870 AD 250 years after death of Muhamamd
  5. Bulug Al Maram Shafi School 1372-1448 AD 700 years after death of Muhamamd (Hadith’s drawn from Bukhari, Muslim, Dawood, Tirmidhi)
  1. 40 Hadith Nawawi 1234-1277 AD 610+years after death of Muhamamd (Abu Zacharia Mohiuddin Yahya ibn Nawawi)
  2. 40 Hadith Qudis Later compilations from other Qurans !!

The closest to Muhamamd is Muwatta Malik, But he has neither seen Muhammad’s companions not the next generation; So the closest is 3 generations separated from events!!!

Now muslims claim these books are written based on a “Golden chain of Transmission” that was orally transmitted through generations;

This method of Orally transmitting through generations from MEMORY is nothing more than the game of “Chinese Whisper”!! –

We have empirical data that 10 people sitting in the same room and same situation and educational/ cultural background can not memorize a story and transmit the same way !! So how can they prove multiple generations did that successfully.

So Hadiths are nothing but “Apocryphal” writings about the history of their religion

Part 2: REGARDING QURAN

Islamic Claims: Muhammad received Quran verbatim from Jibril – The angel, and he memorized it and went back and got others to memorize.

He was faced with issues as people had difficulty memorizing, so Jibril allowed him to memorize in 7 ways called “RECITALS” – Some scholars will call this recitals as AHRUF, Some also call QIRATS, (The Islamic scholars themselves do not have clarity of this )

The Problem for ISLAM:

  1. We know that Dots and Vowels to Arabic language was introduced only in the end of 8th Century and Starting of 9th Century; We have evidence for this; – So the Question is What is the 7 recital Muhammad was given..? was it different readings or different content ..? If the language was only have Consonants then there is no different way of reciting a word with out having vowel sounds!
  2. If Muhammad was given the 7 recital, Why did Zaid Ibn Thabit and Abu Bakar (After Muhamamd’s death) decide to write only one Quran? If the same Quran was to be recited 7 ways, just with Consonantal text (RASM) how do they read..? Does a Muslim know that art..?
  3. If the same quran was read differently why did UTHMA (3rd Khalif) burn all the copies of Quran citing variant reading; and got it re written in Qureshi dialect? A dialect which so fat no linguistic student has been able to trace to Arabia!!
  4. Did Uthman burn written books or just recital (meaning just sounds!!! – That will be stupid to believe)
  5. While Abu Baker was getting the quran written 114 Chapters, there were others like Ubay Ibn Kaab and Masud who claimed 110 and 116 chapters of Quran respectively!! So what are the Variant Qurans that Uthman burnt?
  6. Now if Uthman got everything Re-Written in Qureshi dialect, and sent copies to 5 of their main centers then- Mecca, Medina, Damascus, Khufa and Basra , where are those copies..? What happened to them?
  7. Can any of the available Manuscripts be matched to those Uthmanic recension(TEXT); None of the Manuscript researchers believe so!! (But all Manuscripts match Hafs Quran!!)
  8. Why do we have Qurans created in 8th century as called Qirats? (What happened of the original Qirats given to Muhammad); Here is the list of Qurans Muslims have today

10 QIRATS: (Please note Muhammad died in 632 AD And Last Rashidun Khalif died in 662 AD)

Below 7 ‘Readers’ were Chossen by Ibn Mujahid in 936 AD as Qirats

  1. Nafi Al Madani – Medina 689-785 AD
  2. Ibn Kathir Al Makki Mecca 666-738 AD
  3. Abu Amr Ibn Al Ala Basra 690-770 AD
  4. Ibn Aamir al Damishqi Damascus 736 AD
  5. Aasim Ibn Abi Al Najud Khufa 700-745 AD
  6. Hamzah az zalyyat Khufa 696-771 AD
  7. Al Kisa ‘I Khufa 737-805 AD

Additional ‘readers’ Chossen by Al Jazzari 1429 AD as Qirats

  • Abu Jafar Medina 748AD
  • Yaqub al Yamani Basra 821 AD
  • Khalaf – Khufa 844 AD

These above 10 are the list scholars talk about, that these Qurans have no word/ dot differences; But , These Qurans are written by people who were not even born when Muhammad and His Companions were already dead!! So they are not EYEWITNESSES!! – They just relied on memorization of 2 generations!!

And,

Can Muslims confidently say that there is no differences between these Qurans – As of today 1000’s are getting recorded by the efforts of Christians Scholars and Academicians engaged in the work!!

BUT THE IRONIC PART IS MUSLIMS ANYWAYS DO NOT USE THESE QURANS!!

Each of the above ‘RECITERS’ had 2 – Transmitters (Riwayat) each – Chossen by Al shatibi in 1194 AD (Note- those reciters had other disciples as well; but Al Shatibi randomly selected 2 each of the disciples of the above 10 based on popularity!!)

Here is the list!!- Chosen by Al Shatibi in 1194 AD

Qalun 835 AD Warsh 812 AD

Al Bazzi 864 AD Qunbul 904 AD

Al Duri 860 AD Al Susi 874 AD

Hisham 859 AD Ibn Dhakwan 857 AD

Shu’Bah 809 AD Hafz 796 AD

Khalaf 844 AD Khallad 835 AD

Al-Layth 854 AD Al Duri 860 AD

Additionally added by Al Jazarri

Isa Ibn Wardan 777AD Ibn Jummaz 787 AD

Ruways 853 AD Rawh 849 AD

iSHAQ 899 AD Idris 905 AD

INTERESTING FACTS:

  1. So the canonization of these Qurans did not happen before 300 and 400 years after Muhammad died; Implies There is no validation from 7th century for the Qurans Muslims read today!
  2. As of today we have overall 93000+ difference between the available set of 30+ qurans that are in use
  3. Today 90%+ of world Muslims read Quran written by HAFZ (796 AD)
    • So written 150+ years after death of Muhammad atleast 4 generation of Oral transmitters in between!
    • Hafz was from Khufa – Ironically long back Uthman actually burnt all variant Qurans because people of Khufa were producing variant quran!!
    • Bukhari wrote in his Hadith that Hafz was not at all a credible theologian, he manipulated words meaning, and text!
  • Today 5-6 % of world Muslims (North Africa) read Warsh (812 AD) –
    • WRITTEN 180 + years after death of Muhammad!
    • Between Warsh and Hafz alone there is 5000+ recorded differences as of today and counting , This includes Word changes, sentence changes and theological point changes!!
    • Between Hafz and Original reciters Ibn Aamir ( Damishqi 736 ad) and Aasim Najud (Khufa 745 AD) their is recorded 2500+ differences and counting !!
  • Now we have 6 ancient Manuscripts of Quran: of Which
    • Birmingham Folio predates Islamic time and the story narrated in the manuscript are only stories already found in Christian Apocryphal writings of 3rd and 4th century! – So at best this manuscript only proves that Islam has take material from “Christian Apocryphal writings” Which Christians anyways reject as spurious writings!
    • The Sanna manuscript already shows clear sign of manipulation because there is a overlap of writing erases an older one; and the difference between the older and newer is already more than 70 recorded – this is about the one Sana Manuscript – difference with erased writing!

Is this a credible story of preservation of GOD’s revelation??

If this God is not able to preserve any of the 7th century document and only able to depend on 8th and 9thcentury docs as its original Qirat , doesn’t it clearly expose a more sinister game of a cooked up religion of 8thcentury to control the masses..?

PART 3: SIRAT-UL RASOOL – BIOGRAPHY OF MUHAMMAD

Sirat UL Rasool the biography of Muhammad written by Ibn Ishaq- But the problems;

Islamic sources agree it was written in 760 AD by Ishaq – That is 140 yeasr after death of Muhammad

But the more comic part is Not even one muslim has ever seen the BOOK!!!

They know it so because Ibn Hisham around 820 AD ( 200 years after death of muhamamd) decided he will edit writings of Ishaq – because he concluded there were many embarrassing and unsubstantiated stories about Muhammad in Sirat Ul Rasool ;

So 200 years after death of Muhamamd IBN Hisham came up with a new biography and he claimed he used and edited Ibn Ishaq’s Sirat UL Rasool, So the only testimony muslims have is from Ibn Hisham, and no one has seen original Ibn Ishaq book!!

SO WHAT DO WE CONCLUDE

  1. Oldest Quran used today is written 160 years after Muhammad
  2. Oldest Hadith used today is written 250 years after Muhammad
  3. Only biography we have today written 200 years after Muhammad

Is this the sign of a TRUE RELIGION..?

Continue reading...
 
Top