Looking for answers on ISLAM: Mufti/ Ulema/ Quadi/ Dawah – Please respond

I

Indian

Guest
I am anxiously looking for some answers to the following questions that have developed over a period of time in my mind regarding Allah, Muhammad and Quran

I look forward to hear from one of the Ulema on the following :

REGARDING ALLAH:

  1. If “Tawhid” term is not found in Quran why do you teach that as a major doctrine ?
  2. If Allah’s greatest doctrine is his indivisible – oneness , why does Allah still address himself as “WE/US” in Quran? (Every time I asked this question, I am told this is a sign of majesty and Glory, But that begs the question severely, because if Allah thinks Tawhid is his most important doctrine but still believes that the glory of Plural representation is better and more glorious / majestic than singular pronoun, doesn’t it contradict the core of the doctrine itself?)
  3. Why do you ask Allah to Pray for Muhammad..? Who is is supposed to pray to? Are you claiming there is someone more greater than Allah? (Quran and Shahi Hadith categorically differentiate between Barakat (Blessings) and Sallah (Dua/ Prayer) ;

Here I have added a hadith so you understand the reason for this question:

Ibn Masud (The man about whom muhammad said learn arabic quran for him) – When you bless the prophet make your Prayers (Salah) excellent …. Say, ” O Allah, bestow your PRAYERS ( SALAH), Your Mercy (Rahma) and Your blessings (Barakat) on the master of messengers, …

  1. Salama Al Kindi said – Ali
  2. Quadi ‘Iyad Al Musa Yashubi
  3. Ibn Abbas (Muhammad’s 1st cousin) (QUOTED BY ibn Kathir on Sura 33:56)
  4. Tafsir Ibn Kathir

All clearly distinguish Salah from Barakat and all clarified that Allah was praying

  • The Hadith Al Bukhari said : Abu Al Aliya said…… (While talking about Allah’s Salah and it got confused with Salam.. during conversation.. Kab’in’ Ujrah said.. ” We know about Salam , but how about SALAH? So he was answered then,

O Allah, send your SALAH(Prayer) upon Muhammad….as you send SALAH (Prayer) upon family of Ibrahim; and O Allah, send your BLESSINGS (Barakat) upon muhammad just as you send Blessings (BARAKAT) upon Ibrahim..!!!!!

4.Why does Allah say that he is having a Chin, face, 2 right hands and loins/ groin area that others can put their hand on, and has one eye and is 60 cubits long, don’t you make Allah look like an Evil dragon (Of Fiction)?

5. Allah says he cannot have a son without having sex with a woman; he cannot become Man, but there is a Kalimatuhu (Word of Allah, that proceeds from Allah – So eternal) in Sura 3 who is also called Al Massehu (A person) and he was born in Virgin Mary’s womb by the power of Ruh-Ul Quidis (Spirit that proceeds from Allah) and this Spirit himself became a Man and stood before Mary as per Sura 19;

So the Question- Kalimatuhu and Ruh Ul Quidis can become Man but Allah cannot become Man; Mary can beget a Son as Virgin by work of Ruh Ul Quidis, but Allah cannot think of begetting without Sex!! Dosent it mean Kalimatuhu and Ruh Ul Quidis and Mary all are more capable than Allah when he himself cannot do any of those things as per his own admission..??

6.The word Allah is shown to be the “generic word” for God in Nabatean language; So then what is Allah’s real personal name..? since Allah can communicate and seeks humans, so it implies Allah has a personality and so he requires to have a personal Name; Strangely the Nabatean pagan world called God as Allah and his wife was Al Lat and Al Uzzah; And strangely Quran uses those very names in the infamous Satanic Verses in Quran; by any chance does Allah have his origin in Pagan Nabateans..? How do we prove it is not?

REGARDING QURAN:

  1. Why did Ubay Ibn Kaab and Masud disagree with Zaid Tabit and Abu Bakr on the number of Chapters in Quran? And why did Abu Bakr decide on 114 chapters compared to 110 AND 116 chapters respectively of Quran?
  2. If Quran has got some verses abrogated are those verse present in eternal quran on the Eternal tablet in heaven? Or there also they got abrogated? If eternal then how can it get abrogated? If some verses are getting abrogated by the work of Sahabah after Muhammad’s death and ( Some also by Muhammad ) does not it mean that Humans can destroy the Eternally preserved quran of Allah? So Allah is weaker than all the sahabah..?
  3. Why did Allah not protect the breast feeding verse from the mouth of goat..? If such breast feeding of strangers was important for Muhammad during his time and he got personally involved in protecting those practice as per Hadith why did Sahabah decided that it be abrogated?
  4. If Quran was recited to Muhammad in 7 recitals , why did Abu Bakr get Zaid Ibn Tabit to write only one..? If it was all just the recital part then after 20 years why did Uthman burn all the copies of quran and rewrite form scratch everything in Qureshi Dialect? Was Uthman burning recitals..? spoke words..? What does that even mean..? As per hadith he burnt books, so it was written form of variants!!

It gives rise to too many questions:

  1. Why did Allah not preserve his book
  2. How can man just tamper with an eternally preserved book for which even the dot and vowels are determined in heaven?
  3. If Qirat are the 7 recitals given to Muhamamd by Jibril, then what is Ahruf..? What is the difference between the 2?
  4. As of now we are told there are 10 qirats and 20 Riwayats; How did it become so..? Which one of them is preserved in the Eternal tablet in Heaven..?
  5. Christians are coming up with ALREADY 100000 + Differences between them, and all our Ulema is avoiding the Question, Why..? Why don’t we have answers to these questions..?
  6. More issues:

List of 10 QIRATS and the issue:

7 Readers Chossen by Ibn Mujahid in 936 AD

  1. Nafi Al Madani – Medina 689-785 AD
  2. Ibn Kathir Al Makki Mecca 666-738 AD
  3. Abu Amr Ibn Al Ala Basra 690-770 AD
  4. Ibn AamirAl Damishqi Damascus 736 AD
  5. Aasim Ibn Abi Al Najud Khufa 700-745 AD
  6. Hamzah az zalyyat Khufa 696-771 AD
  7. Al Kisa ‘I Khufa 737-805 AD

Additional readers Chossen by Al Jazzari 1429

  1. Abu Jafar Medina 748AD
  2. Yaqub al Yamani Basra 821 AD
  3. Khalaf – Khufa 844 AD

These above 10 are the list scholars talk about, that there is no word/ dot differences;

Transmitters (Riwayat) – Chosen by Al-Shatibi in 1194 AD

Qalun 835 AD Warsh 812 AD

Al Bazzi 864 AD Qunbul 904 AD

Al Duri 860 AD Al Susi 874 AD

Hisham 859 AD Ibn Dhakwan 857 AD

Shu’Bah 809 AD Hafz 796 AD

Khalaf 844 AD Khallad 835 AD

Al-Layth 854 AD Al Duri 860 AD

Additionally added by Al Jazarri

Isa Ibn Wardan 777AD Ibn Jummaz 787 AD

Ruways 853 AD Rawh 849 AD

iSHAQ 899 AD Idris 905 AD

The earliest of these is Ibn Amir Al Damishqui which was created around 736 AD THAT IS 104 YEARS AFTER DEATH OF MUHAMMAD!!!

  • How can this be one of the Qirat given to Muhammad when already atleast 2-3 generations has passed since his writing? He was not even born when Abu Bakr/ Umar/ Uthman all had already died. So by all means being form Damascus he does not even have a chance to meet all the Sahabah!!
  • How do we believe that the Quran is 100% preserved?
  • If Battle of Yamamam already killed so many of the reciters, and if we have Shahih Hadith full of references to some sahabah mentioning the lack of ability to retrieve any part of some chapters, how can this be a story of Absolute preservation by an eternally powerful GOD..?

My Struggle : Does not all these stories make Islam look like a cooked up religion as a after the fact engineering of disconnected and fanciful stories..?

  1. Can any of the Scholars guarantee that any one of the above mentioned Qurans written by any of those is actually the Abu Bakr version of Quran or the UTHMANIC RECENSION..? (By using some 7th century proof)
  2. So far I know about 6 earliest manuscripts/ folios, including – Sanna, Birmingham, Topkapi, Samarkand, Ma’il … Can any scholar show us that any of these Manuscripts resemble the UTHMANIC RECENSSION AT LEAST?
  3. Why does all these manuscript come close to HAFZ quran that was written about 796 AD (Approx 150 years after death of Muhammad) by a man from KHUFA, The very Qurans Uthman in 655 AD thought of and declared as the corrupted ones)?
  4. Why do most muslims today read the HAFZ quran? What was the basis to accept Hafz quran over all the above mentioned 10 Qirats..? When Hafz is only one of the Riwayats,

I read in Bukhari Hadith that HAFZ was not at all a credible scholar, with all sorts of textual manipulation, and untrustworthy info gathering methods, then what prompted the Islamic scholars to go for HAFZ quran?

  1. Regarding manuscripts:

Sanna Manuscript gives 2 new problems; It looks like the parchment can be potentially dated 30 years before Muhammad started getting revelations (610 AD) So does that mean there is a potential this was some kind of already existing writings used by some one to create a new relegion..?

Secondly the manuscript is showing clear sign of erasing the original writing and overlapping with a new script and writing that comes close to Hafz, So the problem is we can only daye the parchment not the ink, If hafz happened to exist after approx. 200 years of Existance of the parchment, and the use actually happens with in 10 years of the parchment coming into existence for Writing, isn’t this a classic case of tampering?

Moreover dots and vowels in Arabic came into existence in the end of 8th century so any manuscript with dots and vowels can only be from the start of 9th century.

I see that the Birmingham Folio which also boast to be old, only has Sura 18: 17-31 and 19:91-98 and 20:1-40 ; But sadly each of the available story has existed atleast 200-250 years before Muhammad was born in Apocryphal writtings which Christians had rejected 3 centuries earlier itself as Manipulative/ spurious documents; Didn’t Muhammad know all this..? If these stories already existed in such literature, how are these 1st hand revelation to Muhamamd by Allah..? How can Muhammad claim to revelation and also any credibility if he could not distinguish the difference between true literature and false? (Already established facts centuries before even his 10 generation grandfather was even conceived in his mothers womb)

  1. Do you have any 7th century documented proof of existence of a Qureshi dialect in Arabia.. ? I tried hard to find such a dialect in arabia, and no one knows of any proof of existence of such a language. So what is this Qureshi dialtect Uthman is trying to rewrite the Quran in..?
  2. Since Ma’il Manucript boasts of 2/3rd of Quran available, in such case can you show me a Scholarly study that shows Ma’il test absolutely 100% close to Ibn Aamir Damishqui’s Quran (Because as of now available proof says that is the only earliest text you can talk about) I am looking to see if there is any differences between the two.
  3. Why are Christians today showing us 35 + different Qurans – in Arabic with such a heavy list of differences between them, and none of the Islamic scholars seem to want to address this; except for name calling them, none of the Islamic scholars are coming out and showing these Christians the veracity of documents and the proof of preservation of Quran. Why?

INTERNAL CONTRADICTION WITH THE CLAIMS MADE IN QURAN:

  1. Christians show us the case of “ISLAMIC DILEMMA” and I do not see any muslim scholar addressing that.

Muhammad clearly one day asked the JEWS to bring their copy of Torah they have with them; and when it was brought to him, he got up from the “Judgment seat” and placed the copy on the seat, and said by this book you Judge!!

With this action he admitted 2 things

  1. Torah still existed uncorrupted in the hands of Jews atleast till during the time of Muhammad
  2. He thinks he has no right to add anything to Existing Torah for Jews
  3. Torah is greater than him

Conclusion: So now it is easy for us to check and see that The Torah available in 6th century is the very same the Christians and Jews have today in their hands ; Moreover it is same as the one found in Dead Sea Scrolls, that are intact manuscripts 1000 years before Muhammad ever existed!!!!!!

Do you see the blunder of the claim Muslim Scholars are making when they say Torah is corrupted!!!!

Looks like Muslim Scholars and Muhammad both commit stupidity by making such a claim

Moreover,

  • He went on to even state that Allah has advised him that if he is in doubt he should go to “THE PEOPLE OF THE BOOK” (That is the Jews and Christians) and clarify things based on the book they have;

Conclusion: Implies that Allah admitted to Muhammad that neither Torah nor Injil has been corrupted and both clearly exist as given by the true GOD

  • Muhammad claims that Jibril is the one who came to give him revelations, but No one else ever saw Jibril; So you have only the claimants testimony; Infact Aisha narrates an incident when she was in the room with Muhammad and – MUHAMMAD told her that Jibril was standing in the room and talking with him!!! But Aisha also categorically added in that same statement that she turned around and looked and she neither heard anyone’s voice nor did she see any one; But she just trusted what Muhammad said; Isn’t this a classic case of Gullible acceptance of testimony..?
  • Muhammad himself admits that he never saw Allah!!! But The Angel who came to him kept telling him that he is Jibril and Allah has send him with revelations!! But When Muhammad himself doubted this and asked for Sign , Jibril said he is NOT GOING TO have any miraculous sign; Even though he pleaded; The Only thing given is Literary beauty; But as of now there are millions of Original Arabic work that far outclasses the writings of Quran by all and any measure. How does Muhammad convince us that Allah was truly the source of his revelation and the agent who represented the revelation has truly come from the TRUE AND LIVING GOD?
  • If the revelator of Quran was from the TRUE GOD why did his visits make Muhammad desire to commit suicide; he felt he was going mad; he foamed at his mouth and always shivered in panic attack and he himself admits all this and says that every time this revelator came he would choke Muhammad’s neck and leave him breathless; At the same time Muhammad would feel like committing suicide if he does not meet him; Does this not resemble the classic case of schizophrenia, exactly like drug addition and Demon possession that we see today. How is it different?

ABSURD AND FOOLISH DOCTRINES PROPOSED BY ALLAH AND MUHAMMAD:

  1. Stone kissing for Forgiveness of sins: Muhammad says no one (man) can bear another person’s sin, (implying Jesus cannot forgive anyone’s sin) but he taught the muslims that they should go to Kabba and kiss a stone and the stone will take your sin by turning black; Strange a person cannot take your sins but a Stone can bear your sins!!
  2. Muhammad believed innocent can pay for guilty one’s sins: Muhammad says no one can (OR)should bear another person’s sin, but after hijra to medina, he kept doing raids after raids of meccan Business caravan and stole from them; When his companions asked him the reason, he said some people of Mecca looted from his campanions while getting chased out of Mecca; So the innocent business men should pay the price and he is justified!!! Strange now he believes others can be made to bear someone else’s sins!!!!!
  3. Allah did not forgive Muhammad’s Parents: Muhammad claimed Allah can just forgive any ones sins without requiring any payment ; it is purely INshahAllah , But strange Allah did not forgive the sins of THE PARENTS of his most favorite Rasool !!! Muhammad himself admits that both his Father and Mother are already burning in Hell. (Interestingly we do not know of any vile crimes like that of muhamamd which those parents ever committed!!
  4. Muhammad though needing forgiveness can intercede for others, but JESUS the sinless one cannot: Muhammad admitted that JESUS is the only sinless one ever born and added to this Allah also admits to muhammad that Mary mother of Jesus is the only SINLESS WOMAN ever born; But , Muhammad admits about himself that he needed to earnestly plead with Allah for his own forgiveness of sin; But then foolishly goes on to claim that Others can take muhammad’s intercession to enter heaven!!
  5. INTERESTINGLY Jesus as per quranic revelation in Sinless and never died, is in heaven on the throne with Allah!! But intercession possible only by Muhammad!!!

CASE ABOUT THE PERSON MUHAMMAD:

  1. Why did Muhammad get Satanic verses and then he had to change it later? Isn’t it a clear sign of a False prophet? How can you now trust anything he says, when he can be so easily duped by Satan by his own admission?
  2. Muhammad while at Mecca said that if he is a False prophet he will die by the cutting off of his Aaorta. Now on his death bed after eating the poison at the hand of Jewess at Khaibar; Repeatedly confessed to Aisha, Bishir’s Mother and to many of Sahabah – publicly confessing that he is dying because the poison and that it has cut of his Aaorta.
  3. Did Muhammad forget that 10 years back Allah himself gave him such a revelation?
  4. Why did Allah give him such a death that fits exactly 100% into his own description of a False prophet..?
  5. Don’t you think Muhammad himself with his own mouth condemned himself..?
  • Why do you think Muhammad is an example to follow when Quran and Shahih Hadiths is Full of stories of his “SEX CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES”
  • Muhammad said Women and field to be ploughed – Meaning used to penetrate for SEX
  • He discussed the option and use of all cavities found in women to penetrate Penis (Including Anal Sex)
  • He permitted his Sahabah to have wives and SEX SLAVES (Additionally)
  • He instituted a practice called Muttah in which Muslims could use available women as Sex slaves for a few months and then throw them as waste after few months of use
  • He thought he could marry 9 women and have additional Sex slaves
  • One of his wife got angry because he brought a Sex slave to her bed which she caught them red handed on bed; But Allah immediately came to rescue with a revelation justifying his act
  • Muhammad married and consumed sex with a 9 years old “PRE-PUBERTY” Child. We call it Pedophile habits, people get jailed for this now. What should we think of Muhammad..?
  • Muhammad completed stopped a good practice of adoption form Islamic community because one day he saw his own daughter-in law and wanted to marry her; He got his Adopted Son to divorce his wife and thus satisfied his lust ; Then Allah immediately came with a new revelation and legitimized his action by annulling adoption!!! Do you find this disgusting or a good change..??? I feel like vomiting after seeing all this is Quran and Hadith!!
  • When one of his wife (Sauda) grew old and fat, he wanted to divorce her; But the woman was so afraid of a hopeless future, she begged and cried with Aisha to save her ; Finally she negotiated an arrangement to give up the SEX-NIGHT to Aisha and Sauda just being satisfied with food and shelter!!! And Allah immediately came to save Muhammad and appreciate his good example!!! Appalling !!!
  • Muhammad said women testimony is worth only half of Man’s ; so there by he degraded women;
  • Muhammad said property will only go to Man, but no women gets property (she is just a sex toy)
  • He advised men to beat their wives; and that Hell is mostly populated with Women!!
  • All women can be married off or used as sex slave depending on their situation, but his wives nobody can touch and nobody even dare to desire; After his death they must remain widows!!
  • Also ALI has no right to marry another women- Reason give- Because he is HUSBAND TO MUHAMAMD’S DAUGHTER!!!!
  • And all this Allah comes in a timely manner after the fact of these events to help him justify his action with a revelation!!
  • The Heaven Muhammad offered to all Men is one filled with Huris (72 Virgins with raised uptight breast so man can fondle ) and wine; He will get all this if he will die (in Jihad) in the cause of Allah;
  • Christians tell us that this is a clear case of Slave making machinery by Muhammad and his puppet Allah (Figment of Imagination of Muhammad) using all and every method possible to destroy/ kill/ steal/ create a set of legitimized evil actions on earth and give it a color of good deeds!!!
  • Muhammad admitted that Mary mother of JESUS IS THE ONLY SINLESS WOMEN OF WHOLE WORLD, but towards end of his life he claimed he is expecting Allah will give him Mary as his wife for SEX in heaven!!

Is all this the sign of GREATEST EXAMPLE ON EARTH TO FOLLOW!!!!!

Christians think of Islam as blind, ignorant, dark, and stupid..?? How do we answer?

THE UTTER LACK OF HISTORICAL AND SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE OF MUHAMMAD AND REVELATOR AND ALLAH

It is surprising that none of the 3 realized that they were engaging in false stories; They got basic historical facts about Christianity and Science wrong!!

  1. Jesus’s mother is presented as Miriam the daughter of Imran, the sister of Aaron and Moses!! Clearly detailed that leaves no wiggle room for Allah and Muhammad to escape!!

FACTS: Imran Father of Miriam and Moses Aaron, all lived approx. 1500 years before Jesus and all died on their way from Mizraim (Egypt) to Canaan , They were from the Tribe of LEVI

Whereas Mary the mother of JESUS is from family of DAVID of the tribe of Judah and lived 550 years before Muhammad !!! (This is a utter foolishness on the part of Muhammad he could not get basic facts clear)

  • Quran claims JESUS did not die; But Quran was written 600+ years after the fact of Jesus’s death in a land approx. 700+ miles away in a different culture; The fact is just go and look up for Historical documents, and there is reference after reference, and artifacts to prove that JESUS did die on the cross !!! – The most undeniable and provable fact of Antiquity!!

(Note- there are some apocryphal writings of 3rd and 4th century that has these fanciful stories; that is the very reason Christians have long back rejected it; because they are not Eye witness account and they are not accounts corroborated form 1ST century history) ; Isn’t it Muslim responsibility that they corroborate everything with 1st century history and also corroborate Islam’s own history with 7th century documentation..?

  • Quran says Christian Trinity is Father Mother and SON – But this is the most foolish take on TRINITY Christians have ever heard; They are amused as to where did Muhammad get that idea..!!! Through out history form the very 1st century every Disciple of Jesus and Jesus himself consistently said TRINITY is FATHER – JESUS- HOLY SPIRIT
    • FATHER – (JEHOVAH);
    • JESUS (Kalimatuhu and Al Maseehu the WORD OF GOD and The Messiah (Saviour) – The Son of GOD;
    • Holy Spirit of GOD (Ruh Ul Quidis) ;

Now where did you find any scope for a mother here..????

PROBLEMS FORM HISTORIC ANALYSIS

  1. WHY DON’T WE HAVE any artifacts from 7th century with in current Mecca and Medina of Saudi about existence of
  2. Qureshi Dialect
  3. Existence of Muhammad
  4. Existence of the Rashidun Khalifs
  5. Existence of shahadah with muhammad’s name
  6. Why all this exist only from 8th century following? Why nothing in 7th century?
  7. All available coins of 7th century show that there was no Muhammad in Shahadah because they have only 1st part
  8. Why does all the Mosques created in 7th century face PETRA..? Why not Mecca..?
  9. Why do we not see Mecca in any source of 5th/6th/7th Century as an existing town..? Every proof so far we have is only starting 8th century !! Why?
  10. Why does not the description of Mecca as given in Quran fit anything that we know today; But it very clearly fits the PETRA REGION!!
  11. Why does Quran say that Muhammad visited Al Asqa Mosque whereas that mosque was actually build around 700 AD that is around 65 years after the death of Muhammad..?

Is there a sinister piece of history that Islamic scholars are missing..? Or is something being deliberately hidden here..?

  • Why does Islamic scholars keep telling to look up

HAFZ quran written around 760 AD (Approx 150 years after death of Muhammad)

Shahi Hadith of Bukhari and muslim written around approx. 850 AD (Close to 250 years after death of Muhammad)

Sirat Rasool by Ibn Hisham written 200 years after death of Muhamamd

The canonization of Quran only happed in 936 AD Approx 300 years after Muhammad!!

Conclusion:

Whereas Christians call such age difference between factual history and documents as Heretic/ spurious, but Why does Islam consider this their greatest story of preservation..?

How can we prove preservation until we have something from 7th century to match up with and corroborate evidence?

SCIENTIFIC

Scientific details described by Muhammad are too embarrassing even by primary school level standards!!

  1. Muhammad said Sun sets in a Muddy pool in the west and he said Alexander the great actually visited the spot!!
  2. He thought Semen gushed out of ribs near lungs
  3. He believed there are specific ways you can lie down for Sex and get male or female as per choice!!
  4. Hadiths boast about his skills at having sex with all his wives in a single night and walking of to Sallah (Prayer) with semen stains on his cloths which Aisha claims she went around trying to clean up on occasions

This is too much to be a revelation from TRUE AND HOLY GOD by any standards.

I am wondering if any of the available Mufti/ Ulema/ Quadi/ Scholar/ Dawah…

Will come out and explain an answer to all these questions that people like me have;

You guys came out asking me to believe in Allah / Muhammad and Quran; The above mentioned list is my findings and Questions after research;

If it time rather than ranting nasty talk on the person, start giving answers

I am taking this to all and every muslim I know;

You may respond to infinityindian@aol.com

Continue reading...
 
Top